Are We Building Projects, or Building a Transportation System?

I've been thinking about transportation in Canada lately, and something isn't quite adding up for me.

It started with a frustrating experience trying to book a trip with VIA Rail. Around the same time, I was reading about Alto, the proposed high-speed railway between Québec City and Toronto, and its enormous price tag. Here in Québec City, we've been debating the tramway for years. Meanwhile, there are discussions about changes to our airports, highway investments and public transit across the country. And I found myself wondering: how does all of this fit together?

Sometimes it feels as though we're building our transportation system the way someone might build a house, one room at a time, without ever showing anyone the blueprint. We decide to build a railway here, expand a highway there, introduce a tramway somewhere else. Each project might make sense on its own, but how do all the pieces connect? What exactly are we working toward?

As a teacher, I wouldn't plan an entire school year by choosing random lessons every morning. I'd start with the larger objectives and build lessons that connect to one another. So why shouldn't we expect something similar when we're spending billions of dollars on transportation?

And I'm not just talking about trains. I'm talking about highways connecting cities, smaller roads serving towns and villages, buses that get people to work, ferries connecting communities across our waterways, and regional airports serving places where other options are limited. I'm talking about how the Québec City tramway might connect with existing bus routes and surrounding municipalities, or how regional passenger trains could connect with intercity services. Different communities need different solutions, but surely all these pieces should be considered together.

Now, Canada does have a federal transportation strategy called Transportation 2030, and different levels of government already cooperate on transportation issues. So I'm not suggesting that nobody is planning anything. But what I haven't been able to find is a clear, accessible, long-term blueprint that shows ordinary Canadians where we're going. Not just a collection of reports and individual project websites, but something that brings the whole picture together.

Imagine a simple, interactive map of Canada showing the transportation networks we have today and what we're hoping to develop over the next 10, 20 or even 50 years. You could zoom into your own community and see what might be coming. Perhaps a safer highway, an improved road connection, better bus service, a more reliable ferry or easier access to a regional transportation hub. We'd need to distinguish between projects that are funded, those still being studied and ideas that are only possibilities. But wouldn't it be exciting to see how your own town or village might fit into the country's future?

I wonder whether that kind of transparency might change how Canadians respond to major investments. When we hear about billions of dollars going toward a railway, tramway, highway or airport project, it's natural to question the cost and who benefits. Those questions matter, especially for people whose homes, farms or communities may be directly affected. But if we could see how each investment fits into a broader plan, perhaps we'd have a more constructive conversation about our priorities.

Of course, Canada is enormous, and transportation responsibilities are shared among federal, provincial, territorial and municipal governments. Planning something this ambitious wouldn't be simple, and it certainly wouldn't mean building everything at once. But isn't that precisely why we need a long-term vision? Something that survives changes in government, identifies priorities and gives Canadians a way to follow our progress.

I'm not against high-speed rail, tramways, highways or airport investments. I think there's room for all kinds of transportation solutions, depending on where people live and what they need. What I'd like to understand is how we're deciding which projects come first, how they connect, and what kind of transportation system we're ultimately trying to create.

Because before we spend billions building another room, shouldn't we have a blueprint for the whole house?

And wouldn't it be wonderful if Canadians could actually see it?

Sources and further reading

Next
Next

The Freedoms We Take for Granted - Part One - Connecting the Dots